1. Unsalted butter, softened - 1 cup
2. Minced garlic, or more to taste - 1 tablespoon
3. Grated Parmesan cheese - ¼ cup
4. Garlic salt, or more to taste - 1 teaspoon
5. Italian seasoning, or more to taste - 1 teaspoon
6. Ground black pepper, or more to taste - ½ teaspoon
7. Ground paprika, or more to taste - ¼ teaspoon